Panzer Arms M4 Review 2024

Tactical shotguns are a vibrant part of the black-gun market, the incredibly popular and venerable Benelli M4 made the genre of firearms famous. Today we will review a fresh clone of the M4, this one manufactured by Panzer Arms. The Panzer M4 offers all the same features as the original M4, but at a more modest price point.

A great shot-gun that’s reliable and well priced for the market.

Panzer M4 Background

Panzer firearms are manufactured like many others in Turkey. The manufacturers of these arms have been making rifles and shotguns for nearly fifty years. The low cost of manufacturing firearms like these overseas has created a large market of imported arms.

Panzer has made a variety of shotguns for the US market. A surprisingly diverse family of 12 gauge shotguns that could fit nearly any collection. There are AR style shotguns that use the AR manual of arms and detachable box magazines. And for those that love the Kalashnikov design, there are also AK Twelve models that incorporate the AK functions you are familiar with. They even offer their own 20-round drum magazine for the AK Twelve, and Panzer ammo to go with it. There are even bullpup models for all those like me who suffer from a bullish fever.

Panzer Arms are imported to the US by PW Arms out of Washington. And in true PW Arms fashion, they engrave the guns so as to be legible to most satellites and orbiting craft. Panzers are sold all over the country through various dealers, as well as big outfits like Palmetto State Armory. 

Models and Variations

There are other models of the Panzer M4. Most of them are simply variations in finishes and stock options. There is a marine version with black polymer stock and pistol grip, with a nickel plated finish. As well as a standard M4 model with a black finish and pistol grip with either a traditional polymer fixed buttstock, or a skeleton adjustable buttstock. Today’s example uses a walnut stock with the disruptive gray finish.

Panzer M4: Review and Thoughts

I am no stranger to shooting shotguns, but my experience has always been for sport and hunting purposes. Tactical shotguns are used in a slightly different application; instead of applying a volume of shot to increase the likelihood of hitting a moving airborne target, tactical shotguns use the power and shot volume to remove matter from the immediate vicinity of its user. Whether its door hinges, sheetrock, or an uninvited torso, shotguns are great at creating voids where there wasn’t before. 

Shootablity

Panzer’s M4 copy brings all the familiar functions of modern semi-automatic shotguns. The controls are all very familiar and easy to operate well. This made it easy to pick up and get right to shooting. An 18.5-inch barrel makes the gun very easy to maneuver quickly, fast to point and faster to shoot. 

I found the walnut stock to fit my grip and hold very well. If anything I felt like my trigger finger was a touch short for ideal actuating of the trigger. But I quickly got used to it. The oversized safety made it easy to put the gun into fire mode in a hurry. 

I’ve not shot many tactical shotguns, so the ghost ring sights were a little new to me. But I can see why they are popular with these types of guns. They are quick to get on target, and don’t obscure your view much. I also shot the M4 with the new Vortex Defender XL red dot, which was also very nice. The big window and bright dot made it easy to make things disappear downrange.

Reliability

According to what I’ve heard, it’s recommended to run the Panzer M4 on heavier loads for the first bit to help break in the gun. So it didn’t surprise me when a few of the light trap loads I tried didn’t cycle the gun. While I dont think you’ll need to run 3-inch magnums to get the gun to operate reliably, it’s probably fair to assume a defensive tactical shotgun will run on heavier loads. 

The only malfunctions I experienced during testing were under-operation of the action, resulting in a half-ejected hull. These few malfunctions were all with Fiocchi Field Dynamics 1 0z loads. Other similar loads didn’t have these issues, so I think it’s fair to assume the problem was ammo compatibility. 

Again I’ll stress, for a tactical shotgun like this, you would much more likely be running higher velocity buckshot rounds like Winchester SuperX or Hornady Critical Defense. 

The Panzer M4 uses the reliable operating system perfected by Benelli. Dual gas pistons drive the bolt carrier for rugged durability.

Ergonomics

Panzer’s M4 incorporates traditional shotgun ergonomics on this model. The other models also give you the adaptability of pistol grips and adjustable stocks. All of these options are sure to give you an option you like and can shoot well. 

I found the Panzer M4 to be very easy and comfortable as is. The sights lined up well with my eye and natural comb height. With the red dot installed it was just a touch high, but that’s more about the optic mounting than the gun. 

One of the very interesting things about the M4 is the ability to swap the charging handle to the left side of the receiver. This is very convenient for those who prefer charging on the left side.  And makes the gun more adaptable by more people. The only thing I would change on the Panzer M4 would be to make the bolt-release button a little larger. 

Accuracy

Accuracy with shotguns is a bit misleading, as ammunition types and compatibility can vary greatly. If I had some slugs it would be a bit more relevant to this subject, but the traditional shotgun pattern was more than adequate. The M4 comes with three different chokes that allow you to adjust the gun’s patterning to best fit your needs. 

Shooting the M4 at distances where shotguns are useful, I found it to be very easy to hit what you wanted. That’s what makes shotguns so good for close defensive tactics. And it is pretty clear that this gun is a great option for quickly making big holes in things within its range.

Value

A quick search through vendors shows that the Benelli M4 can be had for anywhere between $1500 and $2000. Contrast that with the $500 cost of the Panzer M4 as we tested it today. If the Panzer M4 retains the reliability of the gun it was cloned after, I think it would be hard to argue it wasn’t an incredible value.

Panzer M4 Pros and Cons 

There is quite a bit about the Panzer M4 shotgun to like. There are a couple things I would change about it though. There is a single sling connection point up front. It is a sling loop attachment, but it isn’t solid. It is simply held around the mag-tube with a snap-ring, which makes me feel like it would rattle a lot both when in use and not. The other end of the sling simply has no-where to attach to the butstock. There is no sling swivel or place to attach one on the back of the stock.

Shootability	No surprise that an M4 clone is easy and fun to shoot	A+
Reliability	Function is great, the break-in and need for heavier loads is a small drawback	A-
Accuracy	It’s a shotgun, if you can’t hit your target, don’t blame the M4	A
Value	Compared to its parent, this thing is a steal!	A+

Our Grade

A

Reviewed by Dave Chesson

Reader’s Grade

TBD

Based on 0 Reviews

Your Grade

Do You Own This Gun? Leave A Review

Success Your Grade Has Been
Added To Our Reader’s Score

We use email to verify the accuracy of our reviews. We promise to never spam you.

Henry Homesteader – FAQs

Is the Henry Homesteader ambidextrous?

Yes, the Homesteader is ambidextrous. It has a tang-mounted thumb safety that’s easy to reach from both sides, and the magazine release is also accessible from either side. Plus, you can swap the charging handle to the other side if you’re a lefty.

What’s the best way to use a proper rifle rest?

To get the most out of a rifle rest, set it up on a steady surface. Make sure it’s stable and your rifle sits firmly without wobbling. Adjust the height to fit your position, and when you’re ready, focus on steady breathing and a smooth trigger pull for better accuracy.

What calibers is the Homesteader available in?

The Homesteader is currently chambered only in 9mm, which is the world’s most common cartridge. It is also rated for +P and +P+ ammunition, giving it flexibility for defensive use.

Does the Homesteader have built-in attachment points for slings or other accessories?

Yes, the Henry Homesteader comes with factory-installed sling attachment points, which are ideal for those who want to use a sling for carrying or stability. However, the traditional wooden stock and handguard do not support additional box and handguard attachment systems like modern tactical carbines do. Most additional attachments would be limited to optics on the receiver or muzzle devices on the threaded barrel.

Henry Homesteader Starter Pack

Eye Protection –Eyes are hard to replace, so you will want to have eye protection for all trips to the range.

Hearing Protection – Hearing only gets worse, never better. Get yourself some quality hearing protection to at least slow down your hearing loss.

Gun Cleaning Kit – Check out our favorite gun cleaning kits to help keep all of your firearms well maintained.

First Aid Kit – A first aid kit is a must for range and home.

Slings – We love that the Homesteader came with sling mounts. Here are some of our favorite slings.

Upgrades and Accessories for Henry Homesteader

While the Homesteader does not have accessory rails or MLOK slots, you can improve the aiming by adding a scope rail. You can also get an adapter to fit Glock magazines (or Sig or M&P) so the homesteader is a perfect companion for your carry gun.

Best Ammo for Your Henry Homesteader

Here are some of our favorite 9mm ammunition choices for target and self defense.

Other Pistol Caliber Carbines of its Class to Check Out

The Homesteader has a lot of competition in the best pistol caliber carbine world. Here are some of our favorites to check out.

Reader’s Grade

A

Based on 32 Reviews

Your Grade

Do You Own This Gun? Leave A Review

Success Your Grade Has Been
Added To Our Reader’s Score

We use email to verify the accuracy of our reviews. We promise to never spam you.

We did a head to head comparison of the Homesteader vs the S&W FPC. See which one we thought was the best.

Reader’s Grade

TBD

Based on 0 Reviews

Your Grade

Do You Own This Gun? Leave A Review

Success Your Grade Has Been
Added To Our Reader’s Score

We use email to verify the accuracy of our reviews. We promise to never spam you.

How to Care for Your Henry Homesteader

Here is a video showing you how to disassemble and clean your Homesteader.

Important Links and for the Henry Homesteader

Check out the link below for the manufacturer’s website.