Key Takeaways
- Circuit Judge Christopher Ferebee denied Stand Your Ground immunity to private investigator Kathleen Conran, charged with aggravated assault with a firearm in St. Augustine.
- Conran’s own Meta smart-glasses recording showed her pointing a gun at an unarmed man as he walked away from her.
- The judge found Conran prolonged the confrontation, declined to identify herself, and questioned the man’s right to occupy his home.
- Ferebee found the man was unarmed, never threatened violence, and had already turned away when Conran pointed the gun and threatened to kill him.
- Denying immunity means the aggravated assault with a firearm charge against Conran can move forward, and prosecutors must still prove their case.
Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
ST. AUGUSTINE, FL — A Florida judge has refused to grant Stand Your Ground immunity to a private investigator charged with aggravated assault with a firearm, after finding that her own Meta smart-glasses recording showed her pointing a gun at an unarmed man as he walked away from her.
Circuit Judge Christopher Ferebee ruled on Friday, Nov. 13, that Kathleen Conran, a veteran Duval County-based investigator, is not entitled to immunity from prosecution for a Jan. 24 confrontation on North Orange Street in St. Augustine, as reported by The Citizen.
Conran asked the court to dismiss her felony gun case under Florida’s Stand Your Ground law. She argued she reasonably feared an attack after the man confronted her and followed her toward her truck. After hearings on Oct. 7 and Oct. 14, Ferebee found prosecutors had established that her threatened use of force was unjustified, according to The Citizen. The paper reports the judge found her smart-glasses recording contradicted her claim.
It started with paperwork. Conran was attempting to serve papers in an unrelated case. After speaking with people at a neighboring property, she approached the home the man rented.
The renter testified that he saw her opening his mailbox, removing mail and examining it. Conran denied examining the mail but acknowledged touching the mailbox. Ferebee found the renter’s account consistent with his recorded complaints and later reports, The Citizen reported.
From there, according to the judge’s findings as The Citizen describes them, Conran prolonged the confrontation, declined to identify herself and questioned the man’s right to occupy the home. She then moved fully off the property, and the man began heading back to his front door. Conran said, “Mental illness, take a pill,” according to the order as quoted by The Citizen.
The man approached her vehicle again, demanding that she leave. Then he turned away. The judge found Conran had the gun in her hand while facing him as he walked away. She raised it. She pointed it at him. She acknowledged threatening to kill him while his back was turned, according to the order.
Ferebee acknowledged the man was angry, spoke loudly and used profanity. He also found the man had no weapon and did not threaten violence. The Citizen reports the judge weighed Conran’s age, prior surgeries and physical limitations in evaluating her claimed fear. He also rejected the argument that she merely displayed the weapon. Pointing it while threatening to shoot the man, he found, was threatened deadly force.
On the facts the judge found, this is not a self-defense case, and it is not what Stand Your Ground exists for. Deadly force, and the threat of it, is justified only against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. A man who is loud and profane but unarmed, who never threatened violence, and who has already turned away does not present that threat. Stand Your Ground protects people facing a real threat. It does not turn a heated argument over a mailbox into one, and it does not cover a gun pointed at someone’s back.
The mindset lesson is the unglamorous one. By the judge’s account, the confrontation had a natural end point when Conran stepped off the property and the man headed back to his door. Instead, the comment came, the man came back toward the vehicle, and the gun came up after he had turned around. If you carry, and my Florida concealed carry guide covers the permit side of that, the gun is for stopping a threat to your life. It is not for winning an argument, and when a confrontation is winding down, your job is to let it end.
More from USA Carry:
Conran is charged, not convicted. Denying immunity does not decide guilt. It means the prosecution for aggravated assault with a firearm can move forward, and the state still has to prove its case.
I will continue tracking the case against Conran as it moves forward.
