Defense$12,804.63 to Carry in 46 States: SAF Fact Sheet...

$12,804.63 to Carry in 46 States: SAF Fact Sheet Makes the Case for National Carry Reciprocity

-


Key Takeaways

  • The Second Amendment Foundation released a fact sheet arguing that the right to carry should not end at a state line.
  • One couple spent $12,804.63 obtaining permits to carry legally in 46 states and Washington, D.C.
  • Ten states and D.C. honor no other state’s carry permit, while 29 states now allow permitless carry for eligible adults.
  • Marine veteran Lloyd Muldrow was arrested in Maryland after helping stop an attacker, because Maryland does not honor Virginia carry permits.
  • SAF won a federal court ruling in CRPA v. Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department forcing California to accept nonresident carry permit applications.

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

BELLEVUE, WA — The Second Amendment Foundation has released a new fact sheet arguing that the right to carry should not end at a state line. Its opening line: “In many states, the Second Amendment right to carry is more limited than a driver’s license.”

SAF shared the fact sheet on Facebook with this message:

Download the fact sheet (PDF)

Get the latest articles, DGU stories & a chance to win a free gun! Join the USA Carry newsletter below.

*No Purchase Necessary. See Terms and Conditions for more details.

Where your permit stops working

The fact sheet counts 29 states with permitless carry for eligible adults. Ten states and D.C. honor no other state’s carry permit. Hawaii, Oregon, Illinois and Colorado are marked closed to most visitors.

In between are states that require their own permit but honor some or all permits from elsewhere. Some do that through formal agreements with other states. Others simply recognize out-of-state permits by law, with no agreement needed. You can check where your permit works on my concealed carry reciprocity maps.

A hero, then an arrest

The fact sheet’s case study is Lloyd Muldrow, a Marine Corps veteran whose case I covered previously. On July 4, 2022, he walked into a Baltimore social club after a man had pistol-whipped his friend. He did not draw his own gun. He helped pin the attacker down. He later received the Carnegie Medal for his heroism.

His carry permit was issued by Virginia. Maryland honors no other state’s permits. According to the fact sheet, police officers thanked him, and then arrested him.

The cost of carrying across the country

The fact sheet puts a number on it: $12,804.63. That is what the husband and wife behind the School of the American Rifle YouTube channel have spent to carry in 46 states and D.C. The total counts renewals, required travel and permits they later let lapse. His New York City permit alone cost $1,459 and took a year start to finish. His California permit cost $720.63. His wife skipped both “due to the HIGH costs & required additional training.”

SAF ties those costs to the Supreme Court’s own words. In footnote 9 of N.Y. State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen (2022), the Court wrote that it did “not rule out constitutional challenges to shall-issue regimes where, for example, lengthy wait times in processing license applications or exorbitant fees deny ordinary citizens their right to public carry.” A shall-issue regime is a permit system where the state must issue a permit to anyone who meets the requirements.

Around Washington, a short drive or a few Metro stops can cross three jurisdictions. Maryland and D.C. honor no other state’s permit, so a Virginian who wants to stay armed on routine errands needs two more permits. Maryland requires a 16-hour course from one of its own Qualified Handgun Instructors unless the applicant is exempt. D.C. requires at least 16 hours of training plus two hours on the range.

History and the courts

SAF argues that history sides with the traveler. Many early states and territories restricted concealed carry, and many of those laws exempted travelers. Kentucky’s 1813 ban applied “unless when travelling on a journey.” California in 1863 barred concealed carry by anyone not a “peace officer or traveler.”

In court, SAF was a co-plaintiff in CRPA v. Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department. There, on Aug. 20, 2024, a federal court issued what the fact sheet calls the first-ever court win forcing a state to accept carry permit applications from nonresidents. The same court declined to order California to honor other states’ permits. In the fact sheet’s words, “That takes reciprocity.”

SAF has also filed amicus briefs on the issue in three cases:

  • Gardner v. Maryland, U.S. Supreme Court
  • Duvall v. State, Maryland
  • Johnson v. Jacobson, U.S. Supreme Court

An amicus brief is a filing from a group that is not a party to the case but wants the court to hear its arguments. SAF’s Johnson brief argues that a state “may not refuse to honor the permits issued by other states and insist that every nonresident complete its own redundant licensing scheme.”

More from USA Carry:

The fact sheet goes further than I have here, with a full fee and training comparison, renewal and fingerprint requirements, more historical laws and permit-holder safety data. It is all in the embedded PDF above.

I will continue tracking the push for carry reciprocity, in the courts and in legislation.



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

PSA PA-15 5.56 AR-15 Rifle M4 Carbine BLEM – $479.99

Limited Time Deal If you’ve been waiting for a budget-friendly AR-15 that still...

Springfield 1911 Defender Mil-Spec .45 ACP Package – $579.99

Limited Time Deal Classic American firepower is on sale. The Springfield Armory 1911...

Judge Says Florida PI’s Own Smart Glasses Caught Her Pointing a Gun at an Unarmed Man Walking Away, Denies Stand Your Ground Immunity

Key Takeaways Circuit Judge Christopher Ferebee denied Stand Your Ground immunity to private investigator Kathleen Conran, charged with aggravated...

Aaron Ford’s Gun Control Record Raises Red Flags in Nevada

Nevada gun owners have a new governor to contend with, and his record on the Second Amendment offers...

Baltimore Man Acquitted in Road Rage Shooting After Firing at Motorist Following Him Into Gas Station

Key Takeaways A Baltimore jury acquitted Donell Trusty Jr., 41, on all counts including attempted second-degree murder in a...

Affordability on the Trail, Red Flag Orders on Day One: Texas Democrats File at Least 22 Gun Bills

Key Takeaways Texas Democrats filed at least 22 gun bills on Nov. 9, the first day of filing for...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you