DefenseGOA Testimony to House Oversight Says ATF's 1.4 Billion...

GOA Testimony to House Oversight Says ATF’s 1.4 Billion Out-of-Business Records Are an Illegal, Searchable Gun Registry Congress Must Destroy

-


Key Takeaways

  • Gun Owners of America told the House Committee on Oversight that ATF holds 1,414,088,513 out-of-business firearm records in Martinsburg, West Virginia.
  • GOA says the records are stored in a centralized, searchable digital system that functions as an illegal national gun registry under federal law.
  • ATF Director Robert Cekada told Congress in May 2026 that ATF complies with all laws and does not maintain an illegal firearms registry.
  • A August 2026 DOJ Inspector General audit found the National Tracing Center had not measured whether its crime-gun traces actually help solve crimes.
  • GOA is urging Congress to pass the No REGISTRY Rights Act, H.R. 563 and S. 119, which would require the existing records to be destroyed.

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

WASHINGTON, DC — Gun Owners of America told the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform that the 1,414,088,513 out-of-business firearm records the ATF holds in Martinsburg, West Virginia amount to an illegal, searchable national gun registry that could be turned against law-abiding gun owners, and that the only fix is to delete the records and stop collecting them.

Last week I covered the committee scheduling a hearing for today on ATF’s out-of-business records and GOA’s 1.4 billion record count. What is new is the written testimony GOA Director of Federal Affairs Aidan Johnston put in front of Congress, which lays out in detail how GOA says the system works, why GOA calls it a registry, and what GOA wants the Trump administration and Congress to do about it.

The records at the center of this are the transaction files a federally licensed dealer hands over when it closes. According to GOA, that paper trail starts when a manufacturer stamps a serial number on a gun, follows the gun to a dealer, and ends with a buyer filling out a Firearms Transaction Record, known as Form 4473, after a background check. That form carries the buyer’s name, address, date and place of birth, height, weight, and race, along with the make, model, and serial number of the gun. When a dealer goes out of business, those forms are delivered to ATF under 18 U.S.C. § 923(g)(4).

GOA says ATF scans and stores those forms in a digital, centralized system and that the collection has grown enormous. In a June 10, 2026 letter to Representative Michael Cloud, ATF reported holding 1,414,088,513 out-of-business records as of May 19, 2026, which GOA says is roughly 93 percent digitized. That is up from the 920,664,765 records ATF disclosed to Cloud and 51 other members of Congress in December 2021, of which about 865 million were already digitized.

Get the latest articles, DGU stories & a chance to win a free gun! Join the USA Carry newsletter below.

*No Purchase Necessary. See Terms and Conditions for more details.

ATF counts each page, not each gun or each owner, so the 1.4 billion figure is a page count, not a count of unique buyers. GOA’s testimony concedes that point. Its argument is that even as a page count, the collection is centralized in one federal records center and is searchable by serial number, make, model, caliber, and weapon type. GOA says that is enough to build a list of the owners of a particular kind of firearm, such as AR-15 pistols, without ever searching by name.

Here is where GOA’s case rests on three laws it says ATF has worked around. Federal law bars ATF from writing new rules that require gun registration. It bars ATF from consolidating or centralizing dealers’ records, a restriction first enacted as an appropriations rider in 1978 and made permanent in 2011. And it bars ATF from electronically retrieving these records by a buyer’s name. GOA argues ATF has built a system with full search capability and simply leaves the name field switched off, which means a future administration could switch it back on.

ATF rejects the registry label. In May 14, 2026 testimony to a House Oversight subcommittee, ATF Director Robert Cekada said, “ATF complies with all laws enacted by Congress. We do not have an illegal firearms registry.” Asked whether its tracing database is the same as a searchable national registry of law-abiding gun owners, he said, “There is no searchable gun database for American gun owners,” and told the committee that in the system “the only thing that is actually searchable is a serial number.” In interviews in October 2026, Cekada again denied the agency keeps a registry and said ATF is “100% in compliance with the law.”

Cekada also tried to shrink the number, arguing that only about 3.5 percent of the 1.4 billion pages have been scanned into one high-speed system and that the rest sit in boxes. GOA’s testimony pushes back directly, noting that ATF’s own June 2026 letter counts about 1.309 billion images as already digitized, close to the reverse of what Cekada described. The prior ATF director, Steven Dettelbach, had testified in 2023 that ATF pays extra to have the search function removed from its software, a statement Cekada later said was mistaken. GOA’s point is that either way, the name limit is a choice about how the records are processed, not a hard technological wall.

GOA also raised the security risk of keeping these records at all, pointing to the August 2026 ransomware attack on an ATF system, which the Russian group Qilin claimed. ATF said the affected system was a standalone system that operates separately from its enterprise network, and GOA’s testimony says the attack did not reach the out-of-business records database. GOA’s response is that the next breach could, and that a centralized file of names, addresses, and serial numbers is a target worth eliminating.

GOA also pressed the law-enforcement justification. In the December 2021 exchange, ATF told Congress it has “no ability to determine the successful prosecution” of the crime-gun traces it runs each year. An August 2026 Department of Justice Inspector General audit faulted the National Tracing Center for not measuring whether traces actually help solve crimes. GOA argues that an agency that cannot show the records solve crimes should not be keeping 1.4 billion of them.

On the legal front, GOA, the Gun Owners Foundation, and 17 state attorneys general are still fighting the 2022 Biden-era rule that made dealer records permanent, in Morehouse Enterprises, LLC v. ATF. That case has been stayed in the District of North Dakota while the Justice Department reviews the underlying rule, with no final ruling on the out-of-business records claim. The Trump administration repealed the Biden zero-tolerance inspection policy in 2025, which GOA credits with slowing one driver of forced record transfers.

More from USA Carry:

What GOA wants now is a bigger step. On May 6, 2026, ATF proposed keeping out-of-business records for 20 or 30 years rather than indefinitely. GOA says that does not go far enough, because the retention clock for a dealer and the clock for the National Tracing Center do not run at the same time, which GOA calculates could leave a record in government hands for up to 60 years. GOA’s position is that the correct retention period is zero years, and it is urging passage of the No REGISTRY Rights Act, H.R. 563 and S. 119, which would order the existing records destroyed. As of this testimony, H.R. 563 had 75 cosponsors and S. 119 had 13.

The committee’s hearing on ATF’s out-of-business records retention practices is set for today. I will continue tracking the hearing and whatever the committee does with GOA’s testimony and ATF’s denials.



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

The Evolution of the Battle Rifle: From the FAL to Today’s AR-10

Originally published 11/14/2024. For firearm enthusiasts, military historians, and professional shooters, the battle rifle is revered as a symbol...

Ohio Bill to Punish Cities Over Gun Ordinances Now Carries Permitless Carry at 18 as House Takes Up SB 278

Key Takeaways Ohio Senate Bill 278 began as a fix to let people harmed by city gun ordinances seek...

Minnesota AR-15 and Magazine Ban Planned for 2027

Minnesota Democrats are preparing another attack on the Second Amendment, with incoming House Speaker Zack Stephenson promising to...

Permit Before You Buy: Third Circuit Panel Questions Gun Rights Bid to Block Delaware’s Handgun Permit Law

Key Takeaways A Third Circuit panel questioned gun rights advocates' bid to block Delaware's law requiring a permit before...

Wisconsin Homeowner, 75, Shoots Man Trying to Force Entry

A 75-year-old Wisconsin homeowner fatally shot a 35-year-old man who allegedly grabbed his glasses and attempted to force...

BamaCarry Hands Alabama Lawmakers a 19-Point Program for Freedom Targeting Duty to Inform, Red Flag Orders, Gun Taxes, and Gun-Free Zones

Key Takeaways BamaCarry released a 19-point Program for Freedom asking the Alabama Legislature to repeal the duty-to-inform law, block...

Must read

The Evolution of the Battle Rifle: From the FAL to Today’s AR-10

Originally published 11/14/2024. For firearm enthusiasts, military historians, and...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you