
Twenty U.S. senators are pressuring Amtrak to abandon plans to expand firearm transportation aboard passenger trains, targeting a policy change that would finally allow law-abiding gun owners to transport unloaded, locked firearms on routes without checked-baggage service.
In a November 19 letter to Amtrak Interim President Byl Herrmann, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) and 19 other senators urged the railroad to reconsider its planned January 2027 expansion. The lawmakers raised concerns about passenger safety and demanded answers about how the new procedures would work, giving Amtrak until December 9 to respond.
The proposed changes would permit passengers to transport unloaded firearms and ammunition in specially secured cases aboard certain trains without checked-baggage service. For hunters, competitive shooters, and ordinary gun owners traveling between states, the expansion would remove a longstanding obstacle that has prevented them from bringing legally owned firearms on many Amtrak routes.
As tracked by the AmmoLand 2A NewsRoom, the congressional opposition raises questions about whether the proposed expansion will take effect as planned or face additional political interference before January.
What Amtrak’s New Firearm Transportation Rules Would Allow
Under Amtrak’s currently published firearm transportation policy, passengers may transport unloaded firearms and ammunition in checked baggage on eligible trains. Firearms must be secured in approved, locked, hard-sided containers, and passengers must notify Amtrak at least six hours before departure. The policy also requires passengers to complete a firearm declaration and comply with applicable federal, state, and local laws.
The problem for gun owners is that not every Amtrak train offers checked-baggage service. Under the existing published rules, firearms cannot be transported in carry-on baggage, effectively preventing passengers from bringing their legally owned firearms on routes without the necessary baggage facilities.
The proposed January 2027 expansion would address that restriction. According to the senators’ letter, the changes would permit unloaded firearms and ammunition on certain Northeast Corridor and state-supported routes, including the Northeast Regional, Keystone Service, and Capitol Corridor.
The requirements described in the letter are considerably more restrictive than simply allowing someone to board a train with a firearm in a backpack. Passengers would have to provide six hours’ advance notice and transport their firearms in cases designed to accommodate two separate locking mechanisms. The passenger would supply one lock, while an Amtrak station agent would secure the case with an additional Amtrak-controlled combination lock.
The Amtrak lock would remain in place during the trip and be removed by an agent at the destination. The proposed procedures also involve staffed stations, meaning passengers would not simply be permitted to board wherever they choose with an unsecured firearm.
These details come from information the senators say was provided to Congress and reported elsewhere. Amtrak’s publicly available baggage policy still lists firearms as prohibited carry-on items, and the railroad’s finalized January 2027 procedures have not been independently established through a published Amtrak policy document.
Senate Democrats Object to Locked Firearms in Passenger Cars
Gillibrand, the ranking member of the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Transportation, Housing and Urban Development, is leading the opposition alongside Democratic senators including Chuck Schumer, Dick Durbin, Cory Booker, John Fetterman, and Adam Schiff. Sen. Angus King, an independent from Maine, also signed the letter.
The senators argue that allowing unloaded firearms into passenger cars creates additional security risks, even when those firearms are secured inside locked cases. Their opposition comes despite the proposed requirement that each firearm remain unloaded and secured by two separate locking mechanisms, one of which would be controlled by Amtrak.
The lawmakers also compare the proposed procedures with Transportation Security Administration rules governing commercial air travel. They argue that permitting firearms in passenger compartments would fall short of the separation and screening requirements imposed on airline passengers.
That comparison overlooks an important distinction. The proposed Amtrak policy would not authorize passengers to carry loaded firearms for immediate use or freely access them during travel. It concerns unloaded firearms secured inside cases that, according to the described procedures, would remain locked with an Amtrak-controlled lock until the passenger reaches the destination.
The senators submitted 15 numbered questions addressing the rationale for the policy, safety assessments, employee training, passenger notification, staffing requirements, costs, and the handling of firearms at stations without personnel. They also questioned how Amtrak intends to navigate differing state and local firearm laws.
Although the letter raises operational questions Amtrak will need to address, it does not establish that transporting unloaded firearms under the proposed security requirements would create an unacceptable danger. Instead, the senators are demanding that Amtrak reconsider accommodating law-abiding gun owners before the new procedures even take effect.
Gun-Rights Advocates Defend Expanded Firearm Transportation
The Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms (CCRKBA) has defended the planned expansion, arguing that gun owners should not be denied reasonable transportation accommodations simply because they choose to travel by train.
“Your Second Amendment rights don’t end at the railroad tracks,” CCRKBA Chairman Alan Gottlieb said in a November 9 statement.
CCRKBA maintains that allowing unloaded firearms in securely locked cases is a reasonable accommodation for gun owners traveling by rail. The organization also argues that the proposed procedures would permit firearms to remain under the passenger’s responsibility rather than being handled through a separate baggage system.
The National Rifle Association’s Institute for Legislative Action has also welcomed the planned changes. In its November 16 report, NRA-ILA cited New York Times reporting that Amtrak attributed the policy expansion to efforts to comply with President Donald Trump’s Executive Order 14206, Protecting Second Amendment Rights.
That executive order directed federal officials to review government actions affecting Second Amendment rights. However, the specific Department of Transportation grant conditions reportedly driving Amtrak’s changes have not been independently verified through a publicly available grant agreement.
Federal Funding Could Become the Next Battleground
Gillibrand’s position on the Senate subcommittee responsible for Amtrak’s federal funding adds another dimension to the dispute. The senators contend that the Department of Transportation imposed new conditions on Amtrak’s fiscal year 2026 federal grant, which they characterize as arbitrary.
Those objections raise the possibility that opponents could eventually attempt to use the congressional appropriations process to interfere with the policy. The November 19 letter does not itself impose any funding restriction, and no specific legislative effort to block the expansion has been established in the reviewed sources.
The history of firearm transportation on Amtrak also provides important context. As NRA-ILA notes, Sen. Roger Wicker (R-MS) successfully pushed legislation in 2009 requiring Amtrak to accommodate firearms in checked baggage, reversing the railroad’s previous prohibition. The legislation received bipartisan support and was signed into law by President Barack Obama.
Seventeen years later, the dispute is over whether lawful firearm transportation should remain restricted to trains with checked-baggage facilities or be extended to additional routes under strict storage requirements. For gun owners, the principle is straightforward: choosing passenger rail should not automatically prevent someone from traveling with a legally owned firearm.
What Gun Owners Need to Know Before January 2027
For now, Amtrak’s published rules remain unchanged regarding carry-on firearms. Passengers traveling with firearms must continue using eligible checked-baggage service, provide the required advance notice, and comply with the railroad’s storage and declaration requirements.
The planned expansion would not override state or local firearm laws. That is particularly important for travelers using the Northeast Corridor, where routes cross jurisdictions such as New York, New Jersey, and Maryland, each with its own firearm restrictions. Gun owners must determine whether their particular transportation arrangements comply with applicable laws rather than assume that Amtrak’s permission alone makes the journey legal.
Amtrak has also reportedly permitted unloaded firearms secured inside passengers’ vehicles on its Auto Train since September 1, 2026. That change, described in the senators’ letter, is separate from the planned January expansion affecting passenger cars on routes without checked-baggage service.
The immediate question is whether Amtrak will proceed with the January expansion despite congressional pressure. The senators have requested answers by December 9, but the railroad has not yet published a definitive version of the proposed carry-on firearm policy in the materials reviewed.
For millions of Americans who exercise their Second Amendment rights, the issue is bigger than a change in baggage procedures. It is about whether a federally supported passenger railroad should continue denying lawful firearm transportation on entire routes simply because those trains lack checked-baggage cars.
Allowing properly secured, unloaded firearms on additional routes would be a modest but meaningful improvement for gun owners. The question now is whether Amtrak will follow through or allow political opposition to derail that progress before it takes effect.
About Duncan Johnson:
Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.
