DefenseNRA And SAF Urge Fifth Circuit To Limit Lifetime...

NRA And SAF Urge Fifth Circuit To Limit Lifetime Gun Bans To Dangerous People

-


NEW ORLEANS, LA — The National Rifle Association and Second Amendment Foundation filed a friend-of-the-court brief Wednesday asking the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit to adopt a dangerousness-based test for Second Amendment challenges to the federal lifetime firearm ban for people convicted of felonies.

The Oct. 21 brief in United States v. Cordova supports neither party. Instead, the organizations ask the en banc court to hold that the historical tradition of firearm regulation permitted disarming people shown to be dangerous, not peaceable citizens solely because an offense carried a felony label.

Peter Villa Cordova pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm after a felony conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). His prior convictions include drug possession and evading arrest or detention with a motor vehicle, according to the Fifth Circuit’s May panel opinion.

Cordova preserved an as-applied Second Amendment challenge to the federal statute. A three-judge panel rejected that challenge in May, but the Fifth Circuit granted rehearing en banc in September, vacating the panel disposition and putting the issue before the full court.

Section 922(g)(1) generally prohibits firearm possession by a person convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year in prison. It operates without an automatic end date, making the constitutional standard for as-applied challenges consequential well beyond Cordova’s case.

The NRA and SAF brief argues that colonial and founding-era governments restricted arms based on perceived threats of violence or armed insurrection. It says the historical record does not support a blanket tradition of permanently disarming nonviolent people who have completed their sentences.

The organizations also dispute an argument that founding-era capital punishment for some felonies supplies a historical basis for lifetime disarmament. Their brief says not every felony was capital and argues that linking firearm rights to historical death-penalty eligibility would treat the Second Amendment differently from other rights.

The filing does not decide the appeal and does not establish that Cordova may lawfully possess a firearm. It gives the court a proposed framework for evaluating the constitutional challenge.

The Fifth Circuit’s official en banc calendar says Cordova and a separate Commerce Clause challenge, United States v. Squire, are scheduled for rehearing during the court’s January 2027 session. The court can accept, reject or modify the standard advocated by the amici.

Timeline

Timeline of Cordova: May 20, 2026 panel decision, September 14 en banc rehearing grant, October 21 NRA and SAF amicus brief urging a dangerousness test, and planned January 2027 rehearing.

Legal and safety breakdown

What the court is being asked to assess

The amici’s proposed standard focuses on whether historical analogues support disarming people shown to be dangerous. The federal government may defend § 922(g)(1) under a broader historical theory, and the en banc court is not bound by either framework.

Issue Current law or posture Amici’s position
Federal prohibition § 922(g)(1) bars firearm possession after qualifying convictions. Status alone is too broad for every as-applied challenge.
Historical test Courts compare modern restrictions with the nation’s regulatory tradition. History supports disarming dangerous people, not peaceable citizens as a class.
Case outcome Rehearing is pending. The brief supports neither party and proposes a legal test.

A ruling could clarify how courts in the Fifth Circuit handle individual challenges to the lifetime prohibition. Until then, § 922(g)(1) remains operative.

Safety Tip: A pending constitutional challenge does not suspend a firearm prohibition. Anyone subject to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g) should not possess firearms or ammunition unless a court order or valid restoration process has removed the disability.

Sources



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

ATF Updates Travel Rules for Unregistered SBRs: Form 20 Still Required

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) has updated its guidance for gun owners transporting unregistered...

Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Gun Sales

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit delivered a significant victory for the Second Amendment on...

Zeroing Smarter: Longshot Ranger+ 1,000 Yard

By Ramon Ramirez Posted in #Gear Editor’s Note: In today’s article, the author reviews the Longshot Ranger+ target camera. Longshot provided...

20 Senators Demand Amtrak Scrap Plan to Allow Locked Guns on Trains

Twenty U.S. senators are pressuring Amtrak to abandon plans to expand firearm transportation aboard passenger trains, targeting a...

Out-of-State Driver Woken by Thieves at Georgia Lowe’s Chases Them Down Washington Road, Trading Gunfire Near Midnight

Key Takeaways A man sleeping in a trailer at a Columbia County Lowe's was woken by two males stealing...

Army to Destroy Degraded Lead Azide at Iowa Ammo Plant

By Richard Johnson Posted in #History The U.S. Army plans to destroy roughly five tons of degraded lead azide at the...

Must read

ATF Updates Travel Rules for Unregistered SBRs: Form 20 Still Required

The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you