DefenseMassachusetts High Court Upholds Under-21 Firearm Carry License Restriction

Massachusetts High Court Upholds Under-21 Firearm Carry License Restriction

-


BOSTON, MA — Massachusetts’ highest court upheld the state’s age-21 requirement for a license to carry a firearm, rejecting a facial Second Amendment challenge and affirming the conviction of a man who was 20 when police recovered a handgun he discarded while fleeing a traffic stop.

The Supreme Judicial Court issued its 5-2 decision in Commonwealth v. Thomson on October 20. Justice Gabrielle Wolohojian wrote that restricting firearm possession by people deemed too young to handle guns safely outside supervised settings is consistent with the nation’s regulatory tradition.

Mikai Thomson was a passenger in a car stopped after a red-light violation in December 2021. According to the court, he ran from police and discarded a semiautomatic handgun. He was convicted of carrying a firearm without a license and challenged Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 140, Section 131, which does not permit people under 21 to obtain a license to carry.

The majority assumed without deciding that a person under 21 belongs to “the people” protected by the Second Amendment. It then compared the modern licensing rule with historical militia and youth-possession practices, concluding that both tied younger people’s access to firearms to age, supervision and setting.

The court allowed Thomson to raise a facial challenge, meaning he could argue that the age restriction is unconstitutional in all its applications. It found he lacked standing to pursue an as-applied challenge because he had never applied for or been denied a license.

Two justices dissented from the historical analysis. They would have returned the case to a lower court for a more developed evidentiary record with expert testimony rather than resolving the tradition question on the existing submissions and the court’s own research.

The ruling controls Massachusetts state courts but does not resolve continuing disagreement among federal courts over firearm rights for adults ages 18 to 20. Further review could be sought, and other age-based cases may produce different results under federal appellate precedent.

Timeline

Commonwealth v. Thomson timeline: December 2021 complaint; trial conviction; direct high-court review; March 2026 argument; October 20 decision affirming the conviction.

Legal and safety breakdown

How the court analyzed the challenge

Question Majority conclusion
Does handgun carry implicate the Second Amendment? Yes
Are people under 21 part of “the people”? Assumed without deciding
Did Thomson have an as-applied claim? No, because he never applied for a license
Could he raise a facial challenge? Yes
Is the age-21 rule historically supported? Yes, under the majority’s analogy to supervised youth possession
Result Conviction affirmed

The majority treated founding-era militia rules and laws governing minors as relevant analogues because they linked youth firearm access to responsible adult supervision and limited settings. The dissent did not simply declare the age rule unconstitutional. It argued that the historical record needed fuller development before the court could decide the question.

The ruling concerns Massachusetts’ license-to-carry age restriction and Thomson’s conviction. It should not be read as a nationwide resolution of firearm rights for all 18-to-20-year-olds because other jurisdictions and federal circuits have analyzed similar laws differently.

Safety Tip: Age, residency and license requirements vary sharply by state and can change through litigation. Verify current rules with the issuing authority before carrying or transporting a handgun.

Sources



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Louisiana Sheriff Says Charges Unlikely After Armed Window Intruder Is Killed

MINDEN, LA — A Webster Parish homeowner fatally shot Billy McFarland after authorities say he cut through a...

Holiday Gift Guide for Women: 10 Gifts She’ll Love

Skip the ordinary. Get her something she’ll love and enthusiastically use! I’ve spent years in the firearms industry,...

Michigan Prosecutors Decline Charges In Fatal Portage Car Break-In Confrontation

PORTAGE, MI — Kalamazoo County prosecutors have declined to charge a 54-year-old Portage homeowner in the fatal stabbing...

Texas Resident Shoots Armed Home Intruder During 911 Call

A Texas resident was already on the phone with police when a man who had allegedly threatened to...

SCOTUS Gun Watch 11/16/2026 | Duke Center for Firearms Law

Pending Petitions Case Name Case Number On Appeal From Issue Status Elliot v. United States 26-6139 CA5 Whether a firearm capable of automatic fire is an...

Federal Court Revives Gun Rights Case Over Old DUIs

Two drunk-driving convictions from 1997 and 2005 have kept a New Hampshire man from legally buying a firearm....

Must read

Louisiana Sheriff Says Charges Unlikely After Armed Window Intruder Is Killed

MINDEN, LA — A Webster Parish homeowner fatally...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you