Key Takeaways
- A North Memphis homeowner held an intruder at gunpoint until police arrived after catching him climbing through a window.
- Police found 33-year-old Simeon Pratcher uninjured on the floor when they responded to the call.
- Pratcher believed the home was empty, leading to his arrest on aggravated burglary charges.
- Holding an intruder at gunpoint carries risks, but the homeowner acted in self-defense and complied with police commands.
- Tennessee law allows deadly force if a person believes it’s necessary to prevent imminent harm, justifying the homeowner’s actions.
Estimated reading time: 3 minutes
MEMPHIS, TENN. — A North Memphis homeowner caught an intruder climbing through their window early Tuesday and held the suspect at gunpoint until police arrived, according to the Memphis Police Department.
Officers responded to a shots fired call on Eldridge Avenue just after 1 a.m. When they got inside, they found 33-year-old Simeon Pratcher face down on the bedroom floor with the homeowner standing over him with a firearm.
Officers told the homeowner to put the gun down and then checked Pratcher for injuries. He was not wounded.
Pratcher told police he came through the window because he thought no one was home. He thought wrong. He was arrested without incident and charged with aggravated burglary and possession of burglary tools, Action News 5 reported.
I read stories like this constantly, and the pattern almost never changes. Burglars pick homes they believe are empty. They are not looking for a confrontation. The moment an armed homeowner becomes part of the equation, the entire situation flips.
More from USA Carry:
This homeowner did the right thing being armed and ready in their own house at 1 a.m. Whether to hold a suspect at gunpoint or simply order them back out the window is a personal judgment call, and I do not second-guess anyone who makes that decision in real time. It is worth saying out loud that holding someone at gunpoint carries real risk. The suspect can still fight or try to close the distance. Responding officers walking into the scene also do not always know who the threat is at first glance, which is why complying with officer commands the instant they are given matters as much as the original decision to draw. This homeowner did exactly that.
Tennessee law backs the homeowner here. Deadly force is lawful when a person reasonably believes it is necessary to stop an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury. A stranger crawling through a bedroom window in the middle of the night is precisely the kind of moment the law contemplates.
Pratcher is now facing felony charges. The homeowner is unharmed and back in their own home. That is exactly the outcome a lawfully armed citizen makes possible.
