Key Takeaways
- The First Circuit revived Thomas Marshall’s Second Amendment challenge to a federal gun ban based on two old Massachusetts DUI convictions.
- Marshall was denied a gun purchase in New Hampshire in 2023 because his DUIs carry up to two and a half years in prison, exceeding the federal threshold.
- The appeals court ruled that United States v. Torres-Rosario no longer controls after the First Circuit’s 2026 ruling in United States v. Levasseur requiring the Bruen framework.
- The case returns to the District of New Hampshire only on Marshall’s challenge to the background check denial, not on his standing to challenge criminal possession charges.
- The district court will also consider a Justice Department process under 18 U.S.C. 925(c) that allows prohibited persons to apply for restoration of gun rights.
Estimated reading time: 3 minutes
CONCORD, NH — A federal appeals court on Friday, Nov. 13, revived a New Hampshire man’s Second Amendment challenge to the federal ban that stopped him from buying a gun over two old Massachusetts DUIs. The First Circuit threw out the dismissal of Marshall v. Blanche and sent the case back to the District of New Hampshire for a fresh look under the Supreme Court’s Bruen test.
Thomas Marshall was convicted of DUI in Massachusetts in 1997 and again in 2005. The offense carries up to two and a half years behind bars. That is the problem. 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1) bars gun possession by anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year. The exemption for state misdemeanors only covers those punishable by two years or less.
Marshall moved to New Hampshire in 2023 and tried to buy a gun. New Hampshire State Police told him the FBI had denied him, listing the DUIs as federal disqualifiers. He says he wants a handgun and a long gun for self-defense at home and has not tried again for fear of prosecution.
A federal judge dismissed his suit in June 2025. The judge relied on United States v. Torres-Rosario, a 2011 First Circuit case that largely shut down as-applied challenges to § 922(g)(1), meaning challenges arguing the law is unconstitutional as used against one specific person. The judge called Marshall’s “repeated drunk driving” “ongoing reckless conduct.”
The appeals court said that precedent no longer controls after its Sept. 16, 2026 ruling in United States v. Levasseur, which requires the Bruen framework. Under Bruen, if the Second Amendment covers the conduct, the government has to show the restriction fits the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. The district court never ran that analysis.
The win is narrower than it looks. The panel held that Marshall lacks standing, meaning he has not shown the kind of concrete personal injury a court can fix, to challenge prosecution for simply possessing a gun. The criminal ban only reaches guns that have moved in interstate commerce, and his complaint never said he wants one. With at least 30 licensed firearm manufacturing facilities in New Hampshire in 2023, the court would not assume any gun he bought had crossed state lines.
More from USA Carry:
What goes back is his challenge to the background check denial that blocks him from buying. The panel also pointed to a new Justice Department process under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c) that lets prohibited persons apply to have their gun rights restored. The district court will sort out how that bears on his case.
I will continue tracking Marshall v. Blanche as it returns to the District of New Hampshire.
