DefenseGOA Tells House Oversight the ATF's 1.4 Billion Gun...

GOA Tells House Oversight the ATF’s 1.4 Billion Gun Records Are an Illegal Registry One Software Switch From Name Searches

-


Key Takeaways

  • Gun Owners of America’s Aidan Johnston told a House Oversight subcommittee that the ATF holds 1,414,088,513 firearm records in Martinsburg, West Virginia.
  • Johnston testified that the database can already be searched by make, model, and serial number, and is one software setting away from being searchable by name.
  • Representative Clyde argued that the Firearm Owners Protection Act and a permanent appropriations rider together forbid digitizing the records at all.
  • Ranking Member Casar cited a March 1 shooting on West Sixth Street in Austin that killed three people, saying out-of-business records made tracing the weapons possible.
  • GOA has endorsed H.R. 563, which would require the database be destroyed, and is also in federal court joined by 17 state attorneys general seeking ATF compliance.

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

WASHINGTON, DC — Gun Owners of America‘s director of federal affairs told a House Oversight subcommittee this week that the more than 1.4 billion out-of-business firearm records the ATF stores in Martinsburg, West Virginia are an illegal national gun registry. He said the only thing separating them from a name-searchable confiscation tool is a software setting the ATF itself controls.

Yesterday I covered GOA’s written testimony to the House Oversight Committee laying out why it calls the system a registry. What is new is the hearing itself. GOA’s Aidan Johnston made that case out loud and took questions from both sides of the dais, alongside a retired ATF official, an attorney who represents gun dealers, and a former Biden White House gun violence prevention official.

The hearing was held by the Oversight Committee’s subcommittee on federal law enforcement. Johnston opened with history. In 1978, Ohio Republican Del Latta warned that forcing dealers to report records to the ATF would feed a national data bank and amount to firearms registration. Congress responded that fall by barring the ATF from using its funds to consolidate or centralize dealer records, a prohibition Johnston said is still in effect.

“I am here to tell you that ATF has ignored Congress,” Johnston testified. “The national data bank Congressman Latta warned about now exists right now in a record center in Martinsburg, West Virginia. The ATF holds more than 1.4 billion records that identify which Americans own which guns. Those records are searchable, and they can be weaponized against law-abiding gun owners for mass gun confiscation.”

Get the latest articles, DGU stories & a chance to win a free gun! Join the USA Carry newsletter below.

*No Purchase Necessary. See Terms and Conditions for more details.

The records come from Form 4473, the transaction record a buyer fills out at a licensed dealer. It carries the buyer’s full name, address, date of birth, height, weight, and race, alongside the make, model, and serial number of the gun. When a dealer closes with no successor, federal law requires those records to go to the ATF within 30 days. The ATF scans them into its Out of Business Records Imaging System. Johnston told the subcommittee that as of May the agency reported holding 1,414,088,513 of those records.

His central claim is that the system can already be searched and filtered by make, model, serial number, and weapon type, which he said is enough to build a list of AR-15s for door-to-door confiscation. Search by name is a function the agency has not enabled. Johnston said he coded an app over the weekend in about an hour, and that using technology the federal government already has, search by name and address could be switched on in less than a day.

That point drove the Republican questioning. Subcommittee Chairman Higgins said that calling the system something other than a registry because no one has pushed the button to make it name-searchable is intellectually unsound, and that the danger is not how the records are used today but how they could be used. Representative Biggs pressed the witnesses on what actually makes a collection a registry. He noted that retired ATF official Wally Nelson’s own description of pulling individual images to answer a trace was, in Biggs’s words, another word for searching.

Representative Clyde of Georgia, a federally licensed dealer, read the Firearm Owners Protection Act into the record. That law bars any post-1986 rule requiring that dealer records be recorded at or transferred to a federal facility. It also bars establishing any system of registration of firearms, firearm owners, or firearm transactions. Clyde paired it with a permanent appropriations rider blocking the ATF from spending money to consolidate or centralize dealer records. He argued the two together forbid digitizing the records at all, no matter how long the agency keeps them. Under his questioning, the witnesses agreed the ATF completed out-of-business traces on paper before it began imaging records, and that digital records are not necessary to complete a trace.

Democrats on the panel framed the same records as a crime-fighting tool. Ranking Member Casar of Texas pointed to a March 1 shooting on West Sixth Street in his Austin district that killed three people and injured 15. He said the rifle and handgun used were purchased in 2017, and that out-of-business records are what make it possible to trace a gun years or decades after the sale. Greg Jackson, former deputy director of the White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention, testified that more than half of all crime gun trace requests from 2000 to 2023 ran through out-of-business records. He said 531,520 crime guns had been traced through records older than 20 years, and that destroying them would push criminals toward older, harder-to-trace guns.

The agency’s own position entered the record through others. Higgins, in his opening, said the ATF maintains it follows the law, pulls the records only to trace guns recovered by police in crimes, and points to a Government Accountability Office finding that the system does not currently cross the line into a registry. Jackson said the current Trump-appointed ATF director has stated on the record that the ATF does not have an illegal firearm registry. Jackson also quoted a recent Department of Justice inspector general report: “Nothing came to our attention that caused us to believe the ATF was not in compliance with the laws or regulations.” Nelson, who supervised the ATF’s National Tracing Center from 1998 until he retired at the end of 2005, said he believes the agency complies. He cited three GAO audits since 1996 and an inspector general audit in August of this year.

More from USA Carry:

Everyone at the table agreed the system is used to find records. The disagreement is whether a government database of 1.4 billion gun-and-owner records, searchable by the features of a firearm and one software setting away from being searchable by name, is a registry federal law already forbids. GOA says yes and wants it destroyed. The ATF’s defenders say no and point to the auditors.

GOA has endorsed the No REGISTRY Rights Act, H.R. 563, introduced by Representative Michael Cloud, which would require the database be destroyed and bar the creation of another. The group is also in federal court, joined by 17 state attorneys general, seeking to force the ATF into compliance. Meanwhile, the ATF’s pending proposed rule would cap how long both dealers and the agency keep these records at 20 or 30 years each, where today there is no cap at all. The bill, the rulemaking, and the litigation are all live, and I will continue tracking where they land.



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Gun Theft Prevention Act Targets PLCAA, Tiahrt Protections

Congressional Democrats are once again targeting federally licensed firearms dealers, this time through legislation advertised as an effort...

New Mexico AG Agrees to Injunction Blocking Enforcement of the 7-Day Gun Waiting Period as FPC Files a New Lawsuit the Same Day

Key Takeaways New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez has agreed to an injunction blocking enforcement of the state's seven-day...

U.S. Tech Outages: A Household Outage Checklist And Family Communication Plan

WASHINGTON, DC — A nationwide ground stop on November 13 left U.S. travelers waiting for planes. Three days...

Ayoob: My Custom 1911 by Mike Plaxco

By Massad Ayoob Posted in #Guns Like most who knew the man, I was stunned and saddened on the day in...

The Evolution of the Battle Rifle: From the FAL to Today’s AR-10

Originally published 11/14/2024. For firearm enthusiasts, military historians, and professional shooters, the battle rifle is revered as a symbol...

Ohio Bill to Punish Cities Over Gun Ordinances Now Carries Permitless Carry at 18 as House Takes Up SB 278

Key Takeaways Ohio Senate Bill 278 began as a fix to let people harmed by city gun ordinances seek...

Must read

U.S. Tech Outages: A Household Outage Checklist And Family Communication Plan

WASHINGTON, DC — A nationwide ground stop on...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you